Trump rape accuser’s declare now not a ‘he stated, she stated,’ attorney says as trial begins

NEW YORK, April 25 (Reuters) – E. Jean Carroll’s accusation that Donald Trump raped her was once now not a “he stated, she stated” dispute, a attorney representing the author stated as a civil trial over the previous U.S. president’s behavior just about 3 many years in the past were given underneath means.

Shawn Crowley, who represents the previous Elle mag recommendation columnist, stated right through her opening observation on Tuesday that Trump “slammed Ms. Carroll towards the wall” and “pressed his lips to hers,” an account that different witnesses had been ready to make sure.

“This isn’t a ‘he stated, she stated’ case,” Crowley stated in federal courtroom in Ny.

Crowley spoke after U.S. District Pass judgement on Lewis Kaplan sat 9 jurors who will make a decision whether or not Trump raped Carroll in a division retailer dressing room within the mid-Nineties, and defamed her by means of denying it came about.

In an October 2022 put up on his Reality Social platform, Trump, 76, had known as Carroll’s rape declare a “hoax” and “whole Rip-off,” stated she made it as much as advertise her memoir, and declared Carroll was once “now not my sort!”

Carroll, 79, is looking for unspecified damages for what she calls important ache and struggling, lasting mental hurt, and invasion of privateness.

She invoked a brand new New York state regulation giving grownup sexual abuse sufferers a one-year window to sue their alleged attackers despite the fact that statutes of boundaries expired way back.

The trial is predicted to remaining one to 2 weeks. Trump’s attorney may even give a gap observation.


Carroll’s case is amongst a slew of proceedings and probes going through Trump, the Republican front-runner within the 2024 presidential race. It may well be politically harmful as witnesses speak about Trump’s alleged sexual misconduct, all of which he denies.

The trial started the similar day President Joe Biden, a Democrat, stated he would search a 2d four-year White Area time period.

Trump has lengthy impressed robust emotions from supporters and warring parties around the political spectrum.

Earlier than juror wondering started, Pass judgement on Kaplan ordered Trump’s and Carroll’s legal professionals to inform their purchasers and witnesses to not make statements that would “incite violence or civil unrest.”

He requested potential jurors whether or not they agreed with Trump that the 2020 presidential election was once stolen, or concept the #MeToo motion – which Carroll has stated impressed her to come back ahead – would undercut their impartiality. None stated they did.

Kaplan may be protecting jurors nameless from the general public and the legal professionals, to defend them from possible harassment by means of Trump supporters, or even instructed that jurors now not use their actual names when talking with one any other.

“In case you are in most cases a Invoice and you are decided on for the jury and even ahead of, you’ll be able to be John for a few days,” the pass judgement on advised potential jurors.

Trump was once now not within the courthouse and was once now not required to wait the trial. He was once additionally not likely to testify, consistent with legal professionals from either side.

Former U.S. President Donald Trump speaks on the Nationwide Rifle Affiliation (NRA) annual conference in Indianapolis, Indiana, U.S., April 14, 2023. REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein/Report Photograph

The previous president has time and again attacked Carroll and in private phrases, as soon as calling her mentally unwell, since she first publicly accused him of rape in June 2019.


Carroll stated her stumble upon with Trump on the Bergdorf Goodman retailer came about in overdue 1995 or early 1996.

She stated Trump known her, calling her “that recommendation woman,” and requested for assist in purchasing a present for any other lady.

Carroll stated Trump then “maneuvered” her right into a dressing room the place he close the door, pressured her towards a wall, pulled down her tights and penetrated her. She stated she broke unfastened after two to a few mins.

Her witness checklist contains two pals in whom she stated she confided after the assault, writer Lisa Birnbach and previous information anchor Carol Martin. It additionally contains two different ladies who’ve accused Trump of sexual misconduct, which Trump additionally denies.

Jurors also are anticipated to listen to a 2005 “Get right of entry to Hollywood” tape on which Trump made graphic, vulgar feedback about ladies.

Trump’s legal professionals might attempt to undermine Carroll’s credibility by means of noting that she didn’t name the police, remained publicly silent for greater than 20 years, and can not consider the date and even the month of the alleged assault.

Different criminal problems Trump faces come with Ny District Lawyer Alvin Bragg’s legal fees over hush cash bills to a porn megastar.

Trump pleaded now not responsible to these fees on April 4 at a New York state courthouse, a three-minute stroll from Tuesday’s trial.

The previous president additionally faces:

* Civil fraud fees by means of New York Lawyer Basic Letitia James into his namesake corporate.

* A legal probe into interference in Georgia’s 2020 presidential race.

* A legal probe into categorised govt paperwork recovered at his Mar-a-Lago place of dwelling.

* Inquiries into his function within the Jan. 6, 2021, assault at the U.S. Capitol.

In all of those circumstances, Trump has denied wrongdoing.

Carroll may be suing Trump for defamation after he first denied her rape declare in June 2019, when he was once nonetheless president. That case stays pending ahead of Kaplan.

(This tale has been refiled to proper the attorney’s identify to ‘Shawn Crowley’ from ‘Shane Crowley’ in paragraph 2)

Reporting by means of Jonathan Stempel in New York; Modifying by means of Noeleen Walder and Howard Goller

Our Requirements: The Thomson Reuters Consider Ideas.

Supply By means of